plainly. POLICY & TRAINING

GUIDE

Duty of care and unwise decisions: a quick guide

"We have a duty of care" often gets used to stop people doing things that are their right to choose. Here's how the two fit together.

Take the free Health Check Ask a question

What duty of care means

A duty of care means taking reasonable steps to avoid harm to the people you support. It does not mean preventing every risk, and it does not give you the power to override a decision made by someone who has the capacity to make it.

The right to make unwise decisions

In England and Wales, the Mental Capacity Act 2005 sets out five principles:

  1. Assume a person has capacity unless it is shown that they don't.
  2. Take all practicable steps to help someone make their own decision.
  3. Don't treat someone as unable to decide just because their decision seems unwise.
  4. Anything done for someone who lacks capacity must be in their best interests.
  5. Choose the option that least restricts their rights and freedom.

Principle 3 is the one services most often get wrong. An unwise choice is not, on its own, a sign that someone lacks capacity.

What good practice looks like

  • Talk it through. Make sure the person has the information they need, in a way they can understand.
  • Explore the risk together. Agree ways to reduce it that the person is happy with. This is positive risk taking.
  • Record it. Write down the decision, the risks discussed, the options offered and the person's reasons.
  • Revisit it. If circumstances change, or there is real doubt about capacity for a specific decision, a capacity assessment may be needed.
  • Know when it becomes safeguarding. If someone is at risk of abuse or exploitation by others, or of serious self-neglect, raise it with your safeguarding lead.

Outside England and Wales

Scotland uses the Adults with Incapacity (Scotland) Act 2000. Northern Ireland has the Mental Capacity Act (Northern Ireland) 2016, parts of which are not yet in force. The principles are similar, but the detail and procedures differ, so make sure your policies and training use the right framework.

Last updated November 2026. This guide is general information, not legal advice. Law and guidance differ across England, Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland, so check what applies where you work.

← All guides and checklists

Two minutes. Ten questions. Three fixes.

Take the free Health Check