1. It names someone who has left
Your policy should name your designated safeguarding lead and a deputy, with current contact details. If the person named left months ago, nobody knows who to go to when it matters most.
Quick fix: name a role as well as a person, add a deputy for leave and evenings, and update the names whenever someone changes job.
2. The phone numbers no longer work
Local authority safeguarding teams, children's services, out-of-hours lines and police contacts change more often than you might think.
Quick fix: ring every number in the policy. Put the contacts in an appendix or a separate one-page sheet so you can update them without re-approving the whole policy.
3. It doesn't say how to report a serious incident to your regulator
Charities must tell their regulator about serious incidents, including safeguarding incidents. In England and Wales this is the Charity Commission's serious incident reporting. In Scotland it is OSCR's notifiable events. In Northern Ireland it is the Charity Commission for Northern Ireland's serious incident reporting.
Quick fix: add a short section on who decides whether to report, who submits the report and who tells the board.
4. It covers children or adults, but you now work with both
Services change. A youth project starts a parents' group, or an adult service starts seeing 16 and 17 year olds. Safeguarding adults and safeguarding children follow different legal frameworks, and your policy needs to cover everyone you work with, even occasionally.
Quick fix: list who you work with today, then check the policy covers each group and the right framework for your nation.
5. Your newest volunteer couldn't tell you what to do
This is the real test. Ask a new starter: "If someone told you something worrying tomorrow, what would you do?" If they can't answer in three steps, the policy isn't working in practice, however good it looks on paper.
Quick fix: write a one-page summary with the three steps (listen, record, tell your safeguarding lead the same day) and use it at every induction.
The frameworks behind your policy
- England: the Care Act 2014 for adults, and Working Together to Safeguard Children 2023.
- Wales: the Social Services and Well-being (Wales) Act 2014 and the Wales Safeguarding Procedures.
- Scotland: the Adult Support and Protection (Scotland) Act 2007, and the National Guidance for Child Protection in Scotland.
- Northern Ireland: Adult Safeguarding: Prevention and Protection in Partnership, and Co-operating to Safeguard Children and Young People in Northern Ireland.
Ticked even one? You're not alone. Most charities wrote their policy once, for a funding bid, and never looked back. The fix is rarely a rewrite from scratch.
Last updated November 2026. This guide is general information, not legal advice. Law and guidance differ across England, Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland, so check what applies where you work.